Eighteen Eighty-Five

Meta Info: The time traveler in this round has disguised one of the buildings here as a personal HQ. When submitting your answer, give the answer as your answer PLUS the name of the building. Also, you can click the map above for a larger image, or get it as a fancy PDF.
Doc: The Old West! I can't believe I'm finally here!
Marty: This is heavy, Doc.
Doc: I feel like I share so much with everything around here! And just look at these buildings!
Marty: You should be right at home, Doc.
Changes
2/20/2015, 6:03pm: Added hints - look below.
2/19/2015, 6:03pm: Good, Bad, Ugly - Gregory Jones and Angelina LaFleur have both had their names changed, and Local Information given by Fernandez, Adams, McSamuelson, Hilbert, Wayne, and Travers has been updated.
The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
Scavenger Hunt List [No answer]
Hints?
Feeling Connected
- This is a USC puzzle, and the picture should be a large hint to where we're looking.
- The answer will be found on something we created.
Word Search
- Find words in the grid. What do these words have in common?
- Isn't it strange how most words don't seem to intersect?
Pikachu is Batman
- Googling the title is a fantastic way to start.
- Each sentence can be translated as something else.
The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
- This puzzle uses Knights and Knaves logic.
- The 8x8 grid used will be toured at the end of the puzzle.
Candy!
- Identify the candy. What two general groups could you classify the candies into?
- What is the name of the gumdrop candy mentioned in the title?
Painted Desert
- Identify the artists of the works.
- They fit in the framed grid.
Keyboard Peelers
- Some of these pictures are super specific. What could all these pictures represent?
- The title is a great hint, and "don't be blind" is reference in the opening.
Meta
- Doc feels that he "shares" a lot with the surroundings.
- The lengths of the letters might help when looking at the map.
Upon Solving the Meta...
Time Traveler Captured: Elizabeth
Marty: Wow, who knew Columbia could be this backwards?
Doc: I know! It was enough seeing all these crazy people, but it was just getting out of control.
Marty: Well, at least we discovered the THIMBLE THEATRE, and prevented the wrong line from existing.
Doc: I find this condition disagreeable; let's move on.
Marty: You're right, let's go.